• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • TV/Radio Deals
  • Film partnerships
  • New appointments
  • Production
  • TV Channels
Piracy: the good, the bad and the ugly

Piracy: the good, the bad and the ugly

November 10, 2010
Video Piracy: Separating Fact from Fiction

Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

July 3, 2022
Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

July 3, 2022
Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

July 3, 2022
European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

July 2, 2022
Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

July 1, 2022
Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

July 1, 2022
Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

July 1, 2022
Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

July 1, 2022
Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

July 1, 2022
W Abu Dhabi – Yas Island will be official celebrity host hotel for 22nd IIFA awards

IIFA Awards to return to Abu Dhabi in 2023

June 30, 2022
Neumann launches NDH 30 open-back headphones

Neumann launches NDH 30 open-back headphones

June 30, 2022
Al Aan TV launches two programmes for the summer

Al Aan TV launches two programmes for the summer

June 30, 2022
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Magazine Archive
  • Directory
  • Contact
Sunday, July 3, 2022
BroadcastPro ME
  • News
    • All
    • Podcasting
    • Cinema Theatres
    • Esports
    • TV/Radio Deals
    • Film partnerships
    • New appointments
    • Production
    • Mergers/Acquisitions
    • Satellite/Comms
    • AV
    • OTT/Video Streaming
    • International News
    • Analyst Reports
    • Satellite/Broadcasting
    Video Piracy: Separating Fact from Fiction

    Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

    Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

    Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

    Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

    Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

    European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

    European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

    Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

    Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

    Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

    Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

    Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

    Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

    Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

    Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

    Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

    Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

    W Abu Dhabi – Yas Island will be official celebrity host hotel for 22nd IIFA awards

    IIFA Awards to return to Abu Dhabi in 2023

    Trending Tags

    • broadcast
    • MENA broadcast
    • ConnecTech2019
  • Tech Features
    • All
    • CASE STUDIES
    • Virtual Production Series
    • REVIEWS
    • TV/Radio Deals
    • New Media
    Virtual vernacular: Terminology in virtual production – Part 2

    Virtual vernacular: Terminology in virtual production – Part 2

    The future of subtitling and captioning

    The future of subtitling and captioning

    Redefining cloud for broadcast

    Redefining cloud for broadcast

    beIN Media Group welcomes students as part of French media company initiative

    beIN Media Group welcomes students as part of French media company initiative

    Virtual production: A field guide to the future of filmmaking

    Virtual production: A field guide to the future of filmmaking

    Why converged media consumption requires a converged security solution

    Why converged media consumption requires a converged security solution

    Unlocking the 5G opportunity in video services

    Unlocking the 5G opportunity in video services

    Exploring the power of AI

    Exploring the power of AI

    Disaster recovery in the cloud

    Disaster recovery in the cloud

    There is hope, opportunity, optimism with the cloud

    There is hope, opportunity, optimism with the cloud

    Trending Tags

    • Videos
      Protecting your content – Devising a multi-pronged strategy

      Protecting your content – Devising a multi-pronged strategy

      Gearing up for a FAST audience

      Gearing up for a FAST audience

      Planning Your Hybrid Cloud Playout Journey

      Planning Your Hybrid Cloud Playout Journey

      Qvest on “The cutting edge of Cloud Editing”

      Qvest on “The cutting edge of Cloud Editing”

      Said Bacho on Editshare’s Middle East plans

      Said Bacho on Editshare’s Middle East plans

      Rami Moussawi, Product Manager at ST Engineering iDirect speaks about SKYFlow

      Rami Moussawi, Product Manager at ST Engineering iDirect speaks about SKYFlow

      ASBU BroadcastPro ME Awards Footage

      ASBU BroadcastPro ME Awards Footage

      CEO Panel – Thriving in the New World Order

      CEO Panel – Thriving in the New World Order

      Taking streaming to the next level

      Taking streaming to the next level

    • Opinion
      What we can learn from Korean dramas

      What we can learn from Korean dramas

      Optimising video players for live sports

      Optimising video players for live sports

      New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

      Identifying good stories and investing in content is the need of the hour

      Edging closer to 5G content delivery in the cloud

      Edging closer to 5G content delivery in the cloud

      New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

      Sports brings more subs to platforms

      How to stand out in a content-saturated market

      How to stand out in a content-saturated market

      New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

      Saudi Arabia’s makeover

      Responding to content consumption trends and monetising demand

      Responding to content consumption trends and monetising demand

      A new wave of Saudi filmmakers

      A new wave of Saudi filmmakers

      New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

      Is NFTs the next big thing for creators?

    • Interviews
      • All
      • Lounge
      Akhbar Al Aan on launch of 3eesh Al Aan Café

      Akhbar Al Aan on launch of 3eesh Al Aan Café

      Staying on schedule

      Staying on schedule

      Great expectations at CABSAT 2021

      Setting the stage for CABSAT 2022

      Taking the OTT bull by its horns

      Taking the OTT bull by its horns

      The path to digital transformation

      The path to digital transformation

      The show must go on

      The show must go on

      BeIN at the top of its game

      BeIN at the top of its game

      Giving us the full Viu

      Giving us the full Viu

      Picture Perfect

      Picture Perfect

      Ambassadors of Arabic content

      Ambassadors of Arabic content

    • Products
    • Magazine Archive
      • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
      • PRO Directory
    • Events
      • Upcoming Events
      • News from Events
      BroadcastPro Tech Summit 2022

      BroadcastPro Tech Summit 2022

      BroadcastAsia 2022

      BroadcastAsia 2022

      CABSAT 2022

      CABSAT 2022

      NABSHOW 2022

      NABSHOW 2022

      Future of Sports Broadcasting Summit 2022

      Future of Sports Broadcasting Summit 2022

    No Result
    View All Result
    BroadcastPro ME
    • News
      • All
      • Podcasting
      • Cinema Theatres
      • Esports
      • TV/Radio Deals
      • Film partnerships
      • New appointments
      • Production
      • Mergers/Acquisitions
      • Satellite/Comms
      • AV
      • OTT/Video Streaming
      • International News
      • Analyst Reports
      • Satellite/Broadcasting
      Video Piracy: Separating Fact from Fiction

      Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

      Jerusalem Film Festival reveals lineup of Israeli films

      Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

      Abu Dhabi Media signs broadcasting deal with Serie A

      Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

      Yahsat names Sulaiman Al Ali as Chief Commercial Officer

      W Abu Dhabi – Yas Island will be official celebrity host hotel for 22nd IIFA awards

      IIFA Awards to return to Abu Dhabi in 2023

      Trending Tags

      • broadcast
      • MENA broadcast
      • ConnecTech2019
    • Tech Features
      • All
      • CASE STUDIES
      • Virtual Production Series
      • REVIEWS
      • TV/Radio Deals
      • New Media
      Virtual vernacular: Terminology in virtual production – Part 2

      Virtual vernacular: Terminology in virtual production – Part 2

      The future of subtitling and captioning

      The future of subtitling and captioning

      Redefining cloud for broadcast

      Redefining cloud for broadcast

      beIN Media Group welcomes students as part of French media company initiative

      beIN Media Group welcomes students as part of French media company initiative

      Virtual production: A field guide to the future of filmmaking

      Virtual production: A field guide to the future of filmmaking

      Why converged media consumption requires a converged security solution

      Why converged media consumption requires a converged security solution

      Unlocking the 5G opportunity in video services

      Unlocking the 5G opportunity in video services

      Exploring the power of AI

      Exploring the power of AI

      Disaster recovery in the cloud

      Disaster recovery in the cloud

      There is hope, opportunity, optimism with the cloud

      There is hope, opportunity, optimism with the cloud

      Trending Tags

      • Videos
        Protecting your content – Devising a multi-pronged strategy

        Protecting your content – Devising a multi-pronged strategy

        Gearing up for a FAST audience

        Gearing up for a FAST audience

        Planning Your Hybrid Cloud Playout Journey

        Planning Your Hybrid Cloud Playout Journey

        Qvest on “The cutting edge of Cloud Editing”

        Qvest on “The cutting edge of Cloud Editing”

        Said Bacho on Editshare’s Middle East plans

        Said Bacho on Editshare’s Middle East plans

        Rami Moussawi, Product Manager at ST Engineering iDirect speaks about SKYFlow

        Rami Moussawi, Product Manager at ST Engineering iDirect speaks about SKYFlow

        ASBU BroadcastPro ME Awards Footage

        ASBU BroadcastPro ME Awards Footage

        CEO Panel – Thriving in the New World Order

        CEO Panel – Thriving in the New World Order

        Taking streaming to the next level

        Taking streaming to the next level

      • Opinion
        What we can learn from Korean dramas

        What we can learn from Korean dramas

        Optimising video players for live sports

        Optimising video players for live sports

        New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

        Identifying good stories and investing in content is the need of the hour

        Edging closer to 5G content delivery in the cloud

        Edging closer to 5G content delivery in the cloud

        New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

        Sports brings more subs to platforms

        How to stand out in a content-saturated market

        How to stand out in a content-saturated market

        New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

        Saudi Arabia’s makeover

        Responding to content consumption trends and monetising demand

        Responding to content consumption trends and monetising demand

        A new wave of Saudi filmmakers

        A new wave of Saudi filmmakers

        New normal inspires fresh storylines and alternative filming strategies

        Is NFTs the next big thing for creators?

      • Interviews
        • All
        • Lounge
        Akhbar Al Aan on launch of 3eesh Al Aan Café

        Akhbar Al Aan on launch of 3eesh Al Aan Café

        Staying on schedule

        Staying on schedule

        Great expectations at CABSAT 2021

        Setting the stage for CABSAT 2022

        Taking the OTT bull by its horns

        Taking the OTT bull by its horns

        The path to digital transformation

        The path to digital transformation

        The show must go on

        The show must go on

        BeIN at the top of its game

        BeIN at the top of its game

        Giving us the full Viu

        Giving us the full Viu

        Picture Perfect

        Picture Perfect

        Ambassadors of Arabic content

        Ambassadors of Arabic content

      • Products
      • Magazine Archive
        • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
        • PRO Directory
      • Events
        • Upcoming Events
        • News from Events
        BroadcastPro Tech Summit 2022

        BroadcastPro Tech Summit 2022

        BroadcastAsia 2022

        BroadcastAsia 2022

        CABSAT 2022

        CABSAT 2022

        NABSHOW 2022

        NABSHOW 2022

        Future of Sports Broadcasting Summit 2022

        Future of Sports Broadcasting Summit 2022

      No Result
      View All Result
      BroadcastPro ME
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Opinion

      Piracy: the good, the bad and the ugly

      Staff Writer by Staff Writer
      November 10, 2010
      in Opinion
      ShareTweetPostEmail

      Having worked in anti-piracy for a number of years, it surprises me that people really don?t understand piracy, pirates or their consequences.

      The Stationers’ Company of London in 1557 received a Royal Charter giving the company a monopoly on publication and tasking it with enforcing the charter.

      Those who violated the charter were labelled pirates as early as 1603; now 400 years later…

      Today, broadcast piracy is big business. Everyone has seen internet-connected boxes that will let you watch almost anything that your dish can pick up. The system used by most pirates is control word sharing. This system is very simple – in fact, as long ago as 1998, the system was described by John McCormack, and so was called the McCormack hack. The Conditional Access (CA) vendors were aware of this hack, yet chose to ignore it.

      At that time the internet was very slow, so CA vendors and broadcasters did not see it as a problem. As the internet moved to high-speed broadband, however, control word sharing became technically and commercially viable.

      Common sense would lead you to think that the CA vendors would have been prepared for this, and would have had solutions in place, but this is not true.

      The question is, why?

      This is the part where the piracy story takes a twist. Between 1998 and 2002, most broadcasters suffered from piracy. At the same time, CA vendors were making huge profits. How is this possible? Well, it’s simple. Much of the software used by the pirates actually belonged to the CA vendors, and as the pirates always paid the licence fees to the CA vendors on time, a blind eye was turned to the practice. The vendors were happy selling the smart card chips and cards to the pirates.

      If one were to examine the financial reports, you would find that some CA vendors had a peak in their profits during high levels of piracy. It should be remembered that CA vendors make a large profit from a card swap, whilst the operator is forced to pay out of fear.

      The CA vendors then released the cure to stop the piracy, but, interestingly, this did not protect against control word sharing, which is still the largest form of piracy. Interestingly, the CA vendors knew about this kind of piracy as early as 1988.

      As I once told a CA vendor, you build a big mountain that the pirates can’t climb, so they simply walk around the bottom.

      There have been some interesting and well-publicised court cases recently about CA vendors hacking other CA systems. The most recent involved NDS and Nagra in the US, and both sides claimed victory. Interestingly, even some broadcasters are, or have been, actively involved in piracy.

      Piracy is big business and a lot of money is involved. The average person on the street thinks he is getting something for free, when, in truth, the real price is very high.

      Solutions are difficult to find. CA vendors are now saying that “secure silicon” boxes are the way forward, but even I can see a weakness in these systems. To have a secure system you need to control everything, and most broadcasters will not invest that kind of money.

      CA vendors know that there are very few large broadcasters to sell to. Their interest is in making a profit, and profit for them is in the licences. The broadcaster needs a subscription to make pay TV pay.

      It is very difficult to listen to the so-called experts in CA, when even the chip manufacturers involved are less than economical with the truth about their silicon. When you also see large international companies involved in piracy – albeit at arm’s length – questions need to be asked about the motives of the players.

      You have to ask yourself – is there a cure, or is piracy simply an inevitable cost of doing business? At the end of the day, it is the honest broadcasters and the innocent subscribers that lose. Everyone else still turns a profit.

      Related Posts

      Video Piracy: Separating Fact from Fiction

      Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

      July 3, 2022
      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      July 3, 2022
      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      July 3, 2022
      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      July 2, 2022
      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      July 1, 2022
      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      July 1, 2022

      Related News

      Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

      Viu and True Visions join Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment

      July 3, 2022
      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      Turkey’s RTUK blocks Deutsche Welle and Voice of America over licensing issue

      July 3, 2022
      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      Forum de Beyrouth to host Miss Lebanon 2022 election ceremony on July 24

      July 3, 2022
      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      European Space Agency signs deal with ASECNA

      July 2, 2022
      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      Hope Probe captures new information in fourth batch of scientific data

      July 1, 2022
      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      Broadcast Solutions acquires Thum + Mahr GmbH

      July 1, 2022
      More Related News

      Popular Stories

      • What we can learn from Korean dramas

        What we can learn from Korean dramas

        1311 shares
        Share 524 Tweet 328
      • Abu Dhabi Media appoints StarzPlay as exclusive partner for advertising sales

        730 shares
        Share 292 Tweet 183
      • AD Film Commission organises tour of Abu Dhabi’s key production locations for Indian filmmakers

        674 shares
        Share 270 Tweet 169
      • IIFA Awards to return to Abu Dhabi in 2023

        666 shares
        Share 266 Tweet 167
      • Lebanese film ‘Farah’ wins at Lebanese Independent Film Festival

        648 shares
        Share 259 Tweet 162

      BroadcastPro ME

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Subscribe
      • Magazine Archive
      • Directory
      • Contact
      • Privacy

      Follow us on Social Media

      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Tech Features
      • Videos
      • Opinion
      • Interviews
      • Products
      • Magazine Archive
        • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
        • PRO Directory
      • Events

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Fill the forms bellow to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com