• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • TV/Radio Deals
  • Film partnerships
  • New appointments
  • Production
  • TV Channels
Fighting the legal battle against piracy: Experts at Anti-Piracy Conference

Fighting the legal battle against piracy: Experts at Anti-Piracy Conference

July 1, 2018
SES introduces new platform for live sports distribution

Dentsu launches sports analytics arm in MENA

July 9, 2025
Ad 1
Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

July 9, 2025
Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

July 9, 2025
Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

July 9, 2025
Etisalat collaborates with Moonbug Entertainment

Moonbug releases report on what families truly expect from media and marketing

July 9, 2025
AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

July 9, 2025
Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

July 9, 2025
Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

July 9, 2025
Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

July 8, 2025
ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

July 8, 2025
Exclusive – MediaCast launches second MCX experience centre in Dubai

Exclusive – MediaCast launches second MCX experience centre in Dubai

July 8, 2025
Measat secures IN-SPACe authorisation for satellite services in India via NSIL

Measat secures IN-SPACe authorisation for satellite services in India via NSIL

July 8, 2025
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Magazine Archive
  • Directory
  • Contact
Thursday, July 10, 2025
BroadcastPro ME
  • News
    • All
    • Analyst Reports
    • AV
    • Cinema Theatres
    • Esports
    • Film partnerships
    • International News
    • Mergers/Acquisitions
    • New appointments
    • OTT/Video Streaming
    • Podcasting
    • Production
    • Satellite/Comms
    • TV/Radio Deals
    SES introduces new platform for live sports distribution

    Dentsu launches sports analytics arm in MENA

    Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

    Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

    Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

    Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

    Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

    Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

    Etisalat collaborates with Moonbug Entertainment

    Moonbug releases report on what families truly expect from media and marketing

    AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

    AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

    Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

    Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

    Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

    Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

    Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

    Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

    ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

    ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

    Trending Tags

    • broadcast
    • MENA broadcast
    • ConnecTech2019
  • Tech Features
    • All
    • CASE STUDIES
    • New Media
    • REVIEWS
    • TV/Radio Deals
    • Updates from FOMEX
    • Virtual Production Series
    Breaking free from the hardware cycle: Cloud collaboration in post-production

    Breaking free from the hardware cycle: Cloud collaboration in post-production

    Playing to win

    Playing to win

    The expanding role of AI in broadcast

    The expanding role of AI in broadcast

    The power of podcasts and audio streaming in MENA

    The power of podcasts and audio streaming in MENA

    Tech strategies for an evolving modern MENA media ecosystem

    Tech strategies for an evolving modern MENA media ecosystem

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part IV

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part III

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

    SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

    Transforming the entertainment experience with tech

    Transforming the entertainment experience with tech

    Trending Tags

    • Videos
      FOR-A’s award-winning HVS-Q12: A quantum leap in switcher design

      FOR-A’s award-winning HVS-Q12: A quantum leap in switcher design

      Ignacio Gonzalez-Nuñez on Eutelsat’s new offering and market leadership

      Ignacio Gonzalez-Nuñez on Eutelsat’s new offering and market leadership

      Francesco Cataldo on iKO Media Group’s CABSAT showcase and broadcast trends

      Francesco Cataldo on iKO Media Group’s CABSAT showcase and broadcast trends

      Deepraj Sandhar on Ross Video’s Middle East growth and broadcast tech trends

      Deepraj Sandhar on Ross Video’s Middle East growth and broadcast tech trends

      Reema Omari

      Reema Omari on Universal Satcom’s growth and connectivity solutions

      Mustafa Afifi

      Mustafa Afifi of Rivada Space on Outernet’s impact in the Middle East

      Don

      ST Engineering iDirect CEO Don Claussen on Mideast ties and satellite strategy

      KSASummit

      Transforming Arabic Content: Studios, Producers and Regional Impact

      Bringing Real-Time Audience Insights to Linear Broadcast TV – A First and Exclusive

      Bringing Real-Time Audience Insights to Linear Broadcast TV – A First and Exclusive

    • Opinion
      Survival of the Smartest: Cloud Playout as a Strategic Weapon

      Survival of the Smartest: Cloud Playout as a Strategic Weapon

      Bridging the Latency Gap with Broadcast in a Streaming World

      Bridging the Latency Gap with Broadcast in a Streaming World

      YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

      YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

      Evision’s transformation proves that business acumen and passion drive success

      Sport’s Growing Grip on MENA Media

      MEASA’s media and communications innovations set new benchmarks beyond regional boundaries

      MEASA’s media and communications innovations set new benchmarks beyond regional boundaries

      Integrate ME 2023 brings its inaugural edition to successful conclusion

      Empowering the next generation of content creation and live broadcasting with AV PRO

      Decoding the Ramadan Drama Phenomenon: What Makes a Winner?

      Decoding the Ramadan Drama Phenomenon: What Makes a Winner?

      Reviving cultural identity through native storytelling in Abu Dhabi

      Reviving cultural identity through native storytelling in Abu Dhabi

      Why it’s game on for broadcasters of live sport

      Why it’s game on for broadcasters of live sport

      Evision’s transformation proves that business acumen and passion drive success

      Saudi Arabia emerges as the epicentre of Media & Entertainment in 2025

    • Interviews
      • All
      • Lounge
      Sand, sweat and high stakes

      Sand, sweat and high stakes

      All eyes on AIUIa

      All eyes on AIUIa

      Grass Valley scales up with software and IP workflows

      Grass Valley scales up with software and IP workflows

      Breaking barriers, building futures: The new face of IABM

      Breaking barriers, building futures: The new face of IABM

      New Leadership, Same Strategy, Sharpened Focus

      New Leadership, Same Strategy, Sharpened Focus

      Creating Captain Shedeed: A superhero with Arab roots

      Creating Captain Shedeed: A superhero with Arab roots

      UAE Pro League flips the field

      UAE Pro League flips the field

      Bringing the wild to the Middle East

      Bringing the wild to the Middle East

      Shades of success

      Shades of success

      Navigating the news wave

      Navigating the news wave

    • Products
    • Magazine Archive
      • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
      • PRO Directory
    • Events
      • News from Events
      • Upcoming Events
      DICM

      DICM

      IBC Show

      IBC 2025

      MPTS

      CABSAT2025

      CABSAT2025

      NAB Show

    No Result
    View All Result
    BroadcastPro ME
    • News
      • All
      • Analyst Reports
      • AV
      • Cinema Theatres
      • Esports
      • Film partnerships
      • International News
      • Mergers/Acquisitions
      • New appointments
      • OTT/Video Streaming
      • Podcasting
      • Production
      • Satellite/Comms
      • TV/Radio Deals
      SES introduces new platform for live sports distribution

      Dentsu launches sports analytics arm in MENA

      Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

      Lockheed Martin welcomes 44 interns to tech internship in Abu Dhabi

      Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

      Nokia, CST and partners launch 4.0 GHz neutral host network in KSA

      Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

      Cinema Akil brings back ‘Summer of Classics’ season

      Etisalat collaborates with Moonbug Entertainment

      Moonbug releases report on what families truly expect from media and marketing

      AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

      AFID awards celebrate Arab talent and storytelling

      Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

      Spacetoon teams up with ALJ Sisters for animated series ‘Happiness Spreaders’

      Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

      Maxar secures $205m deals to advance MEA sovereign capabilities

      Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

      Hisense display technology powers VAR wiewing at FIFA Club WC 2025

      ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

      ESA selects five companies for first stage of European Launcher Challenge

      Trending Tags

      • broadcast
      • MENA broadcast
      • ConnecTech2019
    • Tech Features
      • All
      • CASE STUDIES
      • New Media
      • REVIEWS
      • TV/Radio Deals
      • Updates from FOMEX
      • Virtual Production Series
      Breaking free from the hardware cycle: Cloud collaboration in post-production

      Breaking free from the hardware cycle: Cloud collaboration in post-production

      Playing to win

      Playing to win

      The expanding role of AI in broadcast

      The expanding role of AI in broadcast

      The power of podcasts and audio streaming in MENA

      The power of podcasts and audio streaming in MENA

      Tech strategies for an evolving modern MENA media ecosystem

      Tech strategies for an evolving modern MENA media ecosystem

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part IV

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part III

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part II

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

      SMF and FOMEX bring top industry leaders together in Riyadh – Part I

      Transforming the entertainment experience with tech

      Transforming the entertainment experience with tech

      Trending Tags

      • Videos
        FOR-A’s award-winning HVS-Q12: A quantum leap in switcher design

        FOR-A’s award-winning HVS-Q12: A quantum leap in switcher design

        Ignacio Gonzalez-Nuñez on Eutelsat’s new offering and market leadership

        Ignacio Gonzalez-Nuñez on Eutelsat’s new offering and market leadership

        Francesco Cataldo on iKO Media Group’s CABSAT showcase and broadcast trends

        Francesco Cataldo on iKO Media Group’s CABSAT showcase and broadcast trends

        Deepraj Sandhar on Ross Video’s Middle East growth and broadcast tech trends

        Deepraj Sandhar on Ross Video’s Middle East growth and broadcast tech trends

        Reema Omari

        Reema Omari on Universal Satcom’s growth and connectivity solutions

        Mustafa Afifi

        Mustafa Afifi of Rivada Space on Outernet’s impact in the Middle East

        Don

        ST Engineering iDirect CEO Don Claussen on Mideast ties and satellite strategy

        KSASummit

        Transforming Arabic Content: Studios, Producers and Regional Impact

        Bringing Real-Time Audience Insights to Linear Broadcast TV – A First and Exclusive

        Bringing Real-Time Audience Insights to Linear Broadcast TV – A First and Exclusive

      • Opinion
        Survival of the Smartest: Cloud Playout as a Strategic Weapon

        Survival of the Smartest: Cloud Playout as a Strategic Weapon

        Bridging the Latency Gap with Broadcast in a Streaming World

        Bridging the Latency Gap with Broadcast in a Streaming World

        YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

        YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

        Evision’s transformation proves that business acumen and passion drive success

        Sport’s Growing Grip on MENA Media

        MEASA’s media and communications innovations set new benchmarks beyond regional boundaries

        MEASA’s media and communications innovations set new benchmarks beyond regional boundaries

        Integrate ME 2023 brings its inaugural edition to successful conclusion

        Empowering the next generation of content creation and live broadcasting with AV PRO

        Decoding the Ramadan Drama Phenomenon: What Makes a Winner?

        Decoding the Ramadan Drama Phenomenon: What Makes a Winner?

        Reviving cultural identity through native storytelling in Abu Dhabi

        Reviving cultural identity through native storytelling in Abu Dhabi

        Why it’s game on for broadcasters of live sport

        Why it’s game on for broadcasters of live sport

        Evision’s transformation proves that business acumen and passion drive success

        Saudi Arabia emerges as the epicentre of Media & Entertainment in 2025

      • Interviews
        • All
        • Lounge
        Sand, sweat and high stakes

        Sand, sweat and high stakes

        All eyes on AIUIa

        All eyes on AIUIa

        Grass Valley scales up with software and IP workflows

        Grass Valley scales up with software and IP workflows

        Breaking barriers, building futures: The new face of IABM

        Breaking barriers, building futures: The new face of IABM

        New Leadership, Same Strategy, Sharpened Focus

        New Leadership, Same Strategy, Sharpened Focus

        Creating Captain Shedeed: A superhero with Arab roots

        Creating Captain Shedeed: A superhero with Arab roots

        UAE Pro League flips the field

        UAE Pro League flips the field

        Bringing the wild to the Middle East

        Bringing the wild to the Middle East

        Shades of success

        Shades of success

        Navigating the news wave

        Navigating the news wave

      • Products
      • Magazine Archive
        • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
        • PRO Directory
      • Events
        • News from Events
        • Upcoming Events
        DICM

        DICM

        IBC Show

        IBC 2025

        MPTS

        CABSAT2025

        CABSAT2025

        NAB Show

      No Result
      View All Result
      BroadcastPro ME
      No Result
      View All Result
      AMT Ad ibc Ad
      Home Tech Features

      Fighting the legal battle against piracy: Experts at Anti-Piracy Conference

      Supriya Srinivas by Supriya Srinivas
      July 1, 2018
      in Tech Features
      ShareTweetPostEmail

      Speakers on the legal panel at the BroadcastPro ME's Anti-Piracy Conference held on May 2, in Dubai's Ritz Carlton Hotel, advocated more engagement with governments and courts, not less.

      From left: Aditya Verma, Senior Legal Counsel at OSN; Omar Obeidat, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property at law firm Al Tamimi & Co; Waleed Mahboub, Content Director at Diwan Videos; Media Consultant and moderator Eric MacInnes.

      Litigation can be costly, lengthy and at times yields little by way of deterrence. The remedy, the speakers on the legal panel at the BroadcastPro ME’s Anti-Piracy Conference held on May 2, in Dubai’s Ritz Carlton Hotel, insisted, is more engagement with governments and courts, not less.

      In 2016, the administrator of a UAE-based website was charged with illegal streaming of copyrighted content. The punishment included a $13,600 fine, six months in jail and deportation. While this is decisive action, the size of the problem facing content owners is enormous. According to estimates by the International Data Corporation, TV piracy – through the use of illegal set-top boxes (STBs), unauthorised VPN subscriptions and torrent downloads – costs a whopping $750m in losses to content owners and rights holders across the MENA region every year.

      The second panel discussion at the anti-piracy conference hosted by BroadcastPro ME was titled: ‘Addressing Piracy from a Legal Point of View’. Media Consultant and moderator Eric MacInnes, opened by saying: “The object of this panel is to dig deeper and explore what content creators and rights holders can do from the legal and enforcement perspectives.

      “What is the recourse to the law?” he asked the panel, composed of Omar Obeidat, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property at law firm Al Tamimi & Co; Aditya Verma, Senior Legal Counsel at OSN; and Waleed Mahboub, Content Director at Diwan Videos.

      Aditya Verma, Senior Legal Counsel at OSN.

      “It will depend on a case-to-case basis,” said Verma. “whether it is a subscriber who has pirated content, or a pirate IPTV service, or a trademark infringement, and so on. As a first step, we analyse where this piracy is coming from and then we work with our internal content protection and security team to gather as much evidence as possible, and subsequently we involve authorities and external counsel.

      “We can pinpoint the location of pirates in certain cases. Evidence needs to be simplified to be presented to authorities, and that is a challenge, but over time we have fine-tuned the process.”

      “In terms of litigation, does it vary by territory or country?” MacInnes asked Omar Obeidat of Al Tamimi.

      “Fortunately, internet piracy is governed by copyright laws within the purview of which it is a crime,” he responded. “This is a good thing because you get to prosecute the offender with harsh penalties. Presenting evidence and establishing copyright can be a challenge in certain countries. Sometimes you need to go through detailed documentation, so it can be tedious to put together a criminal case. As a legal practioner, our strategy is always to look at bringing the strongest case.

      Omar Obeidat, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property at law firm Al Tamimi & Co.

      “We don’t however rely on the copyright law alone. Our strategy has always been to try a case as an electronic crime, where jail terms are higher than for copyright crimes. Also, the remedies you would have as a content owner are much better if the infringement is deemed an electronic crime. Whether it is a torrent site or the selling of illegal set-top boxes, we still try to present the case as an electronic crime. How do we do that? There must be some sort of electronic deal between the trader who sells the STB and the customer, by way of online subscriptions or online payments. That is enough for a case to be built as an electronic crime.”

      The onus of gathering evidence is on the prosecution, Obeidat said.

      “Onus is always on the content owner. You have to prove that you are the owner and what you are attempting to prosecute is an infringement. Sometimes there are administrative remedies that are better than litigation, especially if you don’t have enough investigation and intelligence-gathering resources. Based on the strength of your case, you take the call.”

      MacInnes then turned to Waleed Mahboub, Content Director at Diwan Videos, a Dubai- and Cairo-based multi-channel network (MCN) and media production company. He asked him: “As a director of content, how attractive does mounting a legal case sound?”

      Waleed Mahboub, Content Director at Diwan Videos.

      “Frankly, it is a long process,” admitted Mahboub. “The best-case scenario is six months to hunt down pirates, accompanied by monetary loss for content owners and broadcasters. However, there is another factor to this piracy ecosystem. Torrent sites are being funded by advertising. I am sure advertisers are not aware as to where their brands are showing – it is a decision typically taken by a digital media agency based on traffic and CPM. This is another element in the fight against piracy that we can pursue. Big advertisers have legal departments, so they are easy to talk to. If we manage to stop advertisements to these sites, we cut their resources.”

      According to a study in 2017 by the US-based Trustworthy Accountability Group (TAG), anti-piracy steps taken by the digital advertising industry have reduced ad revenue for pirate sites by 48-61%, recognised as notable progress against the $2.4bn problem of content infringement.

      “Would you go after advertisers?” Macinnes asked Verma of OSN.

      “This is really an issue of collaboration,” Verma responded, highlighting the underlying question of working with other stakeholders. “A lot of collaboration is happening right now. We work with studios and organisations around the world, including Interpol and Europol. We work with technology providers such as Google and Facebook. Collaboration, however, is a voluntary act, and that is where the challenge lies. Simultaneously the law is evolving and catching up in this region and we have had some good judgements.

      “We need to be creative in our approach, from collaborating to simplifying complex piracy cases with the help of external counsel. One of the other things we also do is ensure that we create awareness not just with the consumers, but also with the authorities. So we have regular workshops in countries such as the UAE, Kuwait, Jordan, Egypt and KSA, and it is an ongoing process because we need to keep up with the pirates.”

      “Is the perception fair that IPR laws in the region are not as advanced as they could be?” asked MacInnes.

      “I would not blame the laws,” Obeidat stressed, adding that they are in keeping with international agreements. Attendees at the conference had earlier raised the issue of lax enforcement and certain cultural issues where domestic copying in the Middle East is often justified in the light of “standing up to Western hegemony”.

      Eric MacInnes, Media Consultant and panel moderator.

      Obeidat continued: “Most countries in the region are signatories to international IP agreements that they signed in the late 1990s and early 2000s. There are cultural issues, however. How do you speak to a judge who does not find this [copyright infringement] terribly wrong, although the law says it is a crime? So the judge will rule the minimum, which could be a slap-on-the-wrist penalty ranging from $500 to $5,000.”

      Obeidat admitted that the penalty was often small compared to the cost of litigation but reiterated that cost was not a primary concern when fighting pirates. Seconding that sentiment, Mahboub said: “In matters of piracy, we should not look at it from the balance-sheet point of view. When I am trying to stop my content from being seen for free, it should not matter how much I pay for litigation.”

      Obeidat stressed the need for deterrence while being creative in the battle against piracy.

      “If we are looking at small-timers selling illegal STBs, we would advise an administrative approach. But if this is a major pirate that has a network, you would want to prosecute the individual or company as a criminal. We have seen this happen both in Kuwait and the UAE with removal of servers, confiscation of equipment and so on. We must prosecute the whole way and try to convey a message of deterrence that as content owners, we will not tolerate such infringement. We must craft the best route possible as well. While in Jordan, we have approached the National Library of Jordan, which is the legal deposit and copyright library for Jordan. We approach the Economic Department in Dubai at the outset rather than the CID.”

      Building on Obeidat’s call to be creative in approaching the fight against piracy, Verma recounted some specific instances.

      “Investigation by private citizens is not permitted, even if your content is being pirated. You need the approval of authorities – you don’t want to be an accessory to a crime” Omar Obeidat, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property, Al Tamimi & Co

      “A lot of times the evidence is dynamic – it keeps changing and is often cross-border when ISPs are involved. With a torrent-based piracy case, we were able to present evidence in a simplified way and the case led to deportation, a fine of $55,000 (AED 200,000) and a six-month jail term. That case set the standard for us. It taught us as to how to approach the authorities, collect evidence and work as a team with them. There is a certain limitation imposed on us by law when it comes to investigating a crime, and that is why we make sure we work with external counsel. We have done this in the UAE and in Jordan.”

      Obeidat warned against the industry taking an ‘I don’t want to bother’ approach to legal cases. “The law does not develop on its own. It needs litigants. For instance, if the industry does not bring cases of illegal online streaming, how would you expect the judiciary to develop its expertise in these areas?”

      Besides the judiciary playing catch-up, Verma built on his earlier point about the complex nature of piracy itself.

      “Defining jurisdiction is a challenge at times when you are looking at dynamic, cross-border evidence. Do we have any protection? Is that particular jurisdiction suitable for us? We need to consider all these aspects. With FTA-related piracy and internet piracy, the crime typically travels across multiple hands and borders. It does not mean we can’t get them, and that’s where industry forums that comprise different stakeholders play a role.”

      At this juncture, Macinnes chose to remind the audience that pirates are often teens or even pre-teens. “Would you prosecute a 12-year-old?” he asked. The question inspired a number of creative options far removed from jails, deportation and confiscation of equipment.

      “If we are able to stop advertisements to these [illegal] sites, we cut their resources” Waleed Mahboub, Content Director, Diwan Videos

      Obeidat spoke of the possibility of using ethical hackers to identify weak links in the content distribution chain and raised the issue of increasing awareness about the menace of piracy among the young. Mahboub questioned the windowing strategies adopted by the region’s broadcasters – the infamous time gap between the US premiere of popular television shows and their eventual broadcast in the region.

      “My four-year-old boy does not understand the concept of waiting for content when he has ready access to content on his tablet. When a 12-year-old cannot find the latest Avengers movie in this region, he will go to a pirated source. Broadcasters should consider the timing of releases and make content readily available to an eager audience.”

      While agreeing with both, Verma reminded the audience that piracy is not a victimless crime.

      Striking a sombre note, he observed: “Regardless of who indulges in piracy, be it a business, adult or teenager, there are victims. We need to create awareness in society about the dangers of supporting illegal content. This is a crime that not only damages the economy of the country but also deters creativity.”

      “We need to be creative in our approach, from collaborating to simplifying complex piracy cases with the help of external counsel” Aditya Verma, Senior Legal Counsel, OSN

      On what constitutes deterrence, there was a range of views, with Verma and Mahboub insisting that sufficient monetary compensation should be awarded to the aggrieved content or rights owner. Obeidat was of the view that jail terms were harsh penalties that would result in deterrence. However, punishments needed to be exemplary, they all agreed.

      Obeidat said: “With statutory minimums, the court always rules the minimum unless you complement the crime with several other crimes such as pornography and so on. I agree with Aditya that there should be statutory damages awarded that are automatically paid, otherwise the content and rights owners are losing – losing with piracy, losing when they litigate, and losing when they see pirates resume their activities because they are not afraid. The judiciary needs to understand that the ruling or verdict must result in deterrence.”

      Verma added: “When a judge presides over a court with nine hardened criminals awaiting trial, for instance, and one individual booked for an IP infringement, he could be mentally unprepared to provide equally harsh penalties on IP infringement as his perspective is influenced. Ideally, the government should ask the industry as to the problems we face and seek solutions from experts, and that could probably help in guiding the judges in terms of the interpretation of the law.”

      As the panel discussion drew to a close, Mahboub urged the industry to think laterally and monitor pirate websites. Netflix famously adopts this not-so-new concept to track what is being illegally downloaded on BitTorrent and pirate sites, to work out what content they should be acquiring.

      Drawing on the regional relevance of the strategy, Mahboub said: “If the source of piracy is a country where regulation is difficult, and these sites are accessible through VPNs, we will never be able to stop piracy 100% unless we convince these countries to criminalise pirates. Monitoring illegal websites for traffic offers insights that will help in the acquisition of content. This is especially helpful for those who do not have sufficient funds to acquire a wide range of content. By understanding what is trending, the window for the release of a title can be adjusted. The moment we see a ripped title, we can offer it at lower price points and eventually we discourage the trend of pirating content.”

      “Our strategy has always been to try a case as an electronic crime, where jail terms are higher than for copyright crimes” Omar Obeidat, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property, Al Tamimi & Co

      Obeidat cautioned against any unilateral initiatives by the industry.

      “My advice is to involve the CID. Investigation by private citizens is not permitted, even if your content is being pirated. You need the approval of authorities – you don’t want to be an accessory to a crime.”

      Lastly, to the suggestion that the MENA region needs specialist judges who understand IP, Obeidat said the move could backfire by creating silos of expertise.

      He observed: “I am all for judges who are informed, but I am also for developing the entire judiciary and elevating the system to better tackle the menace

      Tags: Al Tamimianti-piracyAnti-piracy conferenceDiwan VideosOSN

      Related Posts

      Discovery Channel marks 40th anniversary with special programming

      Discovery Channel marks 40th anniversary with special programming

      June 23, 2025
      OSN partners with Magnite to launch addressable TV advertising

      OSN partners with Magnite to launch addressable TV advertising

      May 19, 2025
      Top Dubai investors join as judges for business reality show ‘The Final Pitch’

      Top Dubai investors join as judges for business reality show ‘The Final Pitch’

      May 14, 2025
      YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

      YouTube in Ramadan: The silent giant

      May 8, 2025
      TOD partners with Cleeng to elevate subscriber experience

      TOD goes live with Friend MTS to tackle piracy in MENA

      May 8, 2025
      Discovery+ now available on OSN+ in MENA

      Discovery+ now available on OSN+ in MENA

      April 9, 2025

      Related News

      TOD goes live with Friend MTS to tackle piracy in MENA

      TOD goes live with Friend MTS to tackle piracy in MENA

      May 8, 2025
      ACE busts one of the world’s largest live sports piracy rings

      ACE busts one of the world’s largest live sports piracy rings

      December 21, 2024
      Meta collaborates with Italy’s Lega Seria A in new anti-piracy effort

      Meta collaborates with Italy’s Lega Seria A in new anti-piracy effort

      December 16, 2024
      1001 expands reach with new ISP partnerships with FiberX and NBTEL

      1001 expands reach with new ISP partnerships with FiberX and NBTEL

      December 5, 2024
      Dubai Police crack down on IPTV piracy ring after Disney Star complaint

      Dubai Police crack down on IPTV piracy ring after Disney Star complaint

      September 30, 2024
      EURO 2024: Record breaking viewership but the fight against sports piracy isn’t over

      EURO 2024: Record breaking viewership but the fight against sports piracy isn’t over

      August 1, 2024
      More Related News

      BroadcastPro ME

      • About
      • Advertise
      • Subscribe
      • Magazine Archive
      • Directory
      • Contact
      • Privacy

      Follow us on Social Media

      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Tech Features
      • Videos
      • Opinion
      • Interviews
      • Products
      • Magazine Archive
        • BroadcastPro ME Magazine
        • PRO Directory
      • Events

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Fill the forms bellow to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In